Thursday, June 19, 2014

Seeing Red, by Kathryn Erskine

Generations of Porters have been fixing cars in Stony Gap, Virginia, "ever since cars were born," as Red Porter's dad told him. His family's street is even called Porter's Shop Road. Red is twelve, but he's been changing oil on his own since he was nine, and Porter's Shop is everything Red loves: oil, gas, paint, brake pads, hoses, filters, Lava soap, old rags, "and a sink with a faucet you could turn on with just your elbow." Barely three pages into the book, I was completely invested in Red's being able to stay in that shop, on this land. Doing so will turn out to be almost impossible, of course, as Red's dad died of a heart attack just weeks earlier, there's no one to run the shop -- and at least part of the land might not even belong to the Porters.

Set in 1972, this rich, layered novel portrays a world in which civil rights and women's rights have barely awakened, and the Vietnam War fills the nightly news. The characters, major and minor, present and face difficult situations like child abuse, racial discrimination, and developmental disabilities. The pastor is a hypocrite. Red's early-childhood friendship with a black boy crumbles because of the pressures they face. Red is temporarily ensnared in a youth version of the KKK. His teacher, who is far from a hippie yet is teaching his class to "think," gets fired for not doing things the way they've always been done. Red, his younger brother, and his mom seem separated and scattered because they grieve in different ways. Worst of all, Red uncovers evidence that his great-great-great grandfather Porter, whose exact name he bears, shot a black man -- ancestor of an elderly woman he deeply admires -- in the back and stole his land. Red has always been proud of the Porter name. Now, he is not so sure.

There's enough plot here to keep the pages turning, and definitely enough impact and literary quality to make this an award contender, I think. This is a novel about small, gradual changes, and small, right choices, adding up to significant progress. While it may not be for the younger or sensitive reader (besides the other difficult subjects, the real-life lynching of Emmett Till is described in some detail), I otherwise highly recommend this.


8 comments:

Barbara Watson said...

This is on my to-read list but my library doesn't have a copy yet. I need to request it, perhaps, and get the ball rolling.

Vijaya said...

I've enjoyed all of KE's books, and this one promises to top the rest. Thanks so much for spotlighting it.

Marcia said...

Barbara -- I've found that most anything I request, my library buys. :)

Vijaya -- This was my favorite of hers so far.

Janet, said...

I've got this one, but haven't read it yet. Thanks for the review.

Marcia said...

Janet -- Hope you enjoy it!

cleemckenzie said...

Set in such an interesting and challenging period, this has to be a great read.

Janet Johnson said...

I got to hear Katherine Erskine speak a couple of years ago, and it was very neat. Sounds like an interesting read. I love the concept of small, right choices leading to something bigger. :)

Marcia said...

Lee -- I enjoy reading historicals from eras I remember. :)

Janet -- I'll bet that was a great presentation.